Back to article list

DR-Inland in Denmark

Sunday, November 15, 2026 • 4:30 PM UTC - in Denmark

It has sparked debate ever since the government first launched the ghetto list back in 2010.

16 years later, we may soon get the Supreme Court’s assessment of whether one of the criteria for being categorised as a disadvantaged housing area is discriminatory.

That is at least the expectation from the lawyers who this week concluded their submissions before seven Supreme Court judges in a case from Helsingør.

At stake is the wording of the government’s definition of a parallel society, previously known as a ghetto area.

The government defines a parallel society as a disadvantaged housing area where the proportion of immigrants and descendants from non-Western countries exceeds 50 percent.

> They have subjected them to massive state-sponsored stigmatisation, and that is in no way helpful for these housing areas.

That definition has previously faced criticism from the UN (https://docs.un.org/en/CERD/C/DNK/CO/22-24), the Advocate General of the European Court of Justice (https://curia.europa.eu/site/upload/docs/application/pdf/2025-02/cp250018da.pdf) and most recently the Council of Europe’s report (https://rm.coe.int/seventh-report-on-denmark/48802e6812) from October, in which the European Commission against Racism and Intolerance (ECRI) criticises Denmark for maintaining the criterion.

"The committee is concerned that the legislative package previously known as the 'ghetto package' has a discriminatory effect on ethnic minorities," a UN committee wrote back in 2022.

"In its previous report on Denmark, ECRI expressed concern over the use of the category 'non-Western' in various laws, policies and administrative practices, including in connection with the legislation on 'parallel societies'," it stated as recently as October in a report from the European Commission against Racism and Intolerance.

Here, the committee regrets that there has been no positive change in the authorities’ approach.

-------------------------------------

Sooner or later they will have to rule

-------------------------------------

But now that seven Supreme Court judges are to make a final ruling on a case from Helsingør, the question and the legality of the ghetto criterion may very well be assessed.

The Helsingør case dates back to 2020. That year, the housing association Boliggården terminated 91 tenancies in the public housing area Nøjsomhed as part of a physical regeneration plan.

The case concerns whether the terminations were unlawful. That is what lawyer Eddie Omar Rosenberg Khawaja, who represents the tenants, argues, while lawyer Henrik Qwist, who represents BoliggĂĄrden, denies it.

But Eddie Omar Rosenberg Khawaja has also argued that the use of the non-Western background criterion in the parallel society legislation violates the prohibition against ethnic discrimination, and that is where the principle is at stake.

A full seven Supreme Court judges are to assess the case, and that only happens when matters of principle are involved, says lawyer Henrik Qwist.

- When seven wise Supreme Court judges sit together, I don’t think they will take the easy way out. I think they will choose to decide it because they know that if these seven judges don’t do it now, these High Court cases will continue and later come before the Supreme Court.

- Sooner or later they will have to rule on it, so why not do it now? I think they will, says Henrik Qwist.

A case concerning Mjølnerparken in Copenhagen and Schackenborgvænge in Slagelse is among those awaiting treatment by the High Court.

© Ritzau Scanpix

--------------------

Minister of Housing responds

--------------------

DR has asked for a comment from the Minister of Housing, Jacob Mark (Socialist People's Party), on the Helsingør case and the criticism of the non-Western background criterion in the parallel society legislation.

In a written statement, Jacob Mark says:

*

- For reasons of principle, I am very reluctant to comment on specific cases that are being heard by the courts.

*

- At this point, I therefore see no reason to comment on the case concerning the housing area Nøjsomhed in Helsingør, which is an ongoing court case in the Supreme Court. The same applies to other ongoing court cases, including those concerning the parallel society legislation.

*

- That said, I would like to emphasise that the parallel society effort is one of the most important societal efforts we have in Denmark, and the government will continue a strong and clear parallel society effort within the guidelines set by the courts. The effort must ensure that the positive development that has already lifted both people and housing areas across the country is maintained.

The tenants’ lawyer, Eddie Omar Rosenberg Khawaja, also expects that the Supreme Court will assess the legality of the government’s use of the criterion concerning immigrants and descendants from non-Western countries in relation to whether a housing area can be categorised as a parallel society.

- If the Supreme Court addresses this criterion, it means that the regulations made for those housing areas are in fact not legal, believes Eddie Omar Rosenberg Khawaja.

-----------

Contentious case

-----------

Associate Professor Troels Schultz Larsen from Roskilde University has researched stigmatised housing areas, housing social initiatives and the connection between labour market policy, social policy and housing policy for the last 15-20 years.

He explains that the criticism from the UN, the Advocate General of the European Court of Justice and the Council of Europe reflects that internationally eyebrows are raised over Denmark’s use of this criterion.

- As something rather unique in Denmark, we have this statistical and political category of ethnic minorities and descendants from non-Western countries. The question then is whether this type of categorisation constitutes ethnic discrimination when it is used to select specific housing areas or specific stairways and to legislate in various ways, he says.

Several residents from Mjølnerparken have complained to the European Court of Justice about the ghetto law because they believe it violates the prohibition against ethnic discrimination. (Photo: © Sergei Gapon, AFP/Ritzau Scanpix)

He calls the case contentious because Denmark has linked ethnic categorisation to the ghetto concept and the parallel society concept, and that this has contributed to stigmatising specific housing areas.

- We now see that various types of lists are also emerging in Sweden, Norway and other countries that are moving in the direction of the Danish list, but Denmark has clearly been at the forefront, and that is also something that has been criticised from a research perspective.

- On the one hand, the message has been to avoid these housing areas. At the same time, they have been subjected to massive state-sponsored stigmatisation, and that is in no way helpful for these housing areas, says the associate professor.

Read also: Thousands forced out of their homes: Court could convict Denmark of discrimination (https://www.dr.dk/nyheder/indland/tusindvis-tvunget-ud-af-deres-hjem-domstol-kan-doemme-danmark-diskrimination)

----------------------------------

Helsingør case has awaited EU ruling

----------------------------------

Back to the case from Helsingør. The Housing Court in Helsingør and later the Eastern High Court in 2022 ruled in favour of Boliggården, finding that the terminations back in 2020 were lawful.

But since 2022, the case has awaited hearing in the Supreme Court, which has awaited a ruling from the European Court of Justice in December 2025. This concerns another similar case from Denmark.

Read also: Risk of 'direct discrimination' in Danish ghetto law, assesses EU court (https://www.dr.dk/nyheder/indland/risiko-direkte-diskrimination-i-dansk-ghettolov-vurderer-eu-domstol)

The Advocate General of the European Court of Justice, Tamara Ćapeta (https://www.dr.dk/nyheder/indland/ny-vurdering-i-eu-den-danske-ghetto-lov-forskelsbehandler-paa-baggrund-af-etnicitet), assessed in February 2025 that the division into "Western" and "non-Western" immigrants and their descendants is based on ethnic origin, and that it constitutes "direct discrimination" when Danish legislation on public housing – previously referred to as the "ghetto law" – among other things assesses areas based on ethnicity.

This occurred after residents from, among other places, Mjølnerparken in Copenhagen chose to take legal action (https://www.dr.dk/nyheder/regionale/hovedstadsomraadet/beboere-i-mjoelnerparken-staevner-staten-diskrimination-og) to defend their homes against being sold, as they believed it was a case of discrimination.

> The parallel society effort is one of the most important societal efforts we have in Denmark, and the government will continue a strong and clear parallel society effort within the guidelines set by the courts.

Subsequently, the European Court of Justice established that the criterion of "non-Western origin" can constitute discrimination, but that it is up to Danish courts to make the final assessment.

-------------------------------------

Could lead to overturning legislation

-------------------------------------

Professor at the Faculty of Law at Aarhus University, Louise Halleskov, also believes that the selection of seven Supreme Court judges indicates that this case is considered a matter of principle.

- One must assume that they will tell us something general about how they interpret the European Court of Justice's ruling, and there is a possibility that the Supreme Court will tell us whether they believe these criteria in the Public Housing Act constitute direct or indirect discrimination, she says.

- That would not only have significance for the specific case (from Helsingør, ed.). It would also have direct significance for the other cases pending at, among others, the Eastern High Court concerning this so-called ghetto legislation.

What consequences it could have if the Supreme Court rules that this violates the prohibition against ethnic discrimination, we will for obvious reasons not know until the verdict is delivered on 23 November.

But if the Supreme Court concludes that it in fact constitutes direct discrimination on the grounds of ethnicity, "it would be a real overturning of the legislation, and then this legislation would have to be amended," points out Professor Louise Halleskov.

- But there is also another possibility, and that is that they "merely" make a ruling in the specific case, she says.

Warning: This article was translated by a Large Language Model, in case of doubt, you can always visit the original source.